Join my VIP mailing list for email alerts on new books! Join my VIP Mailing List

The Man and Woman Who Beat Smallpox

Vaccination reduces 400,000 deaths a year to none

Edward Jenner vaccinates James Phipps, 1798
Edward Jenner vaccinates James Phipps, 1798
Sunday, April 4, 2021

If you have a scientific bent, you have probably heard of Edward Jenner, an English surgeon and scientist who is credited with the discovery of vaccination against smallpox. Born in Gloucestershire in 1749, Jenner was the eighth of nine children of the local vicar and his wife. Jenner was apprenticed at fourteen to a surgeon and in 1770 he moved to London to complete his training.

Two years later, Jenner returned to Berkeley in Gloucestershire to become the local doctor and surgeon. One of his regular tasks was to help guard his patients against smallpox by a procedure called variolation. (And I’ll come back to this later.)

Edward Jenner

Smallpox got its name in 16th Century Britain, to distinguish it from syphilis, which was known as the ‘great pox’. It is a highly infectious disease caused by the Variola major and Variola minor virus variants. Nobody knows exactly where it came from, but some of the earliest instances have been found in Egyptian mummies from the 3rd Century BCE. During the last hundred years—up to the last known naturally-occurring case in 1977—smallpox is thought to have killed 500 million people, with approximately 300 million of those deaths taking place since 1900. The overall mortality rate was thirty percent, although some strains of the disease were noted to be almost invariably fatal.

In Edward Jenner’s time, outbreaks of smallpox across Europe accounted for one third of all cases of blindness, and 400,000 deaths a year. But, for some years Jenner had been intrigued by local country lore which claimed that dairymaids never got smallpox.

This was because they tended to catch cowpox, which appeared to offer them protection against smallpox. Cowpox is a mild viral infection in cows, causing a few similar symptoms, although to a far lesser degree and without apparent discomfort. Humans developed a few weeping pocks on their hands and felt unwell for a few days.

When Sarah Nelmes, a local dairymaid, came to see Jenner in 1796 with pocks on her hand, the doctor took the opportunity to gather some of the pus. He tested his theory on the eight-year-old son of his gardener, a boy called James Phipps, by making scratches on one of James’ arms and infecting these with some of the material from Sarah’s hand.

A few days later, James developed mild cowpox, but soon recovered. Six weeks later, Jenner inoculated the child with smallpox, which had no effect. Jenner concluded that James was now immune, and to prove his theory, inoculated the poor kid another twenty times. James never caught the disease, which might be considered reward enough, but Jenner later gave him a free lease on a cottage in Berkeley.

Jenner published an account of his vaccination of James Phipps in 1798, becoming the first person to do so, although he was not the first to carry out vaccination using cowpox. Most notably, Benjamin Jesty of Dorset in 1774, inoculated three members of his family, and Peter Plett from Kiel in what is now Germany in 1791, inoculated three children.

Up until the new method of vaccination with cowpox became the norm, the only protection against smallpox was variolation. (See, I promised I’d come back to that.) This practise developed in Asia, possibly as early as the 16thCentury. It involved exposing someone to a very small dose of smallpox—taken either from a smallpox patient, or a recently variolated patient. The idea was that this person would contract a mild form of the disease, and would then be immune.

Lady Mary Wortley Montagu
Lady Mary Wortley Montagu

Usually, scabs from the smallpox pustules were dried and then blown up the nose of the person being inoculated, which sounds delightful. It wasn’t without risk, either—between one and two percent of those receiving variolation died as a result. Still better odds than catching full-blown smallpox, however.

By 1700, variolation had spread from Asia to Africa, India, and the Ottoman Empire. It was in Constantinople in Turkey that Lady Mary Wortley Montagu first learned about variolation. Lady Mary (1689-1762) was the wife of the British ambassador. She survived a bout of smallpox in 1715, but had suffered the subsequent scarring. Her brother had died of the disease two years earlier.

Perhaps because of these events, she was keen to protect her own children. In 1718, while still in Turkey, she had her five-year-old son inoculated by a process of ‘engraftment’—inserting smallpox under the skin. This was carried out with the help of Charles Maitland, the surgeon at the Embassy. Her daughter was too young to undergo the procedure at the time. It was only after Lady Mary returned to England, and a smallpox epidemic broke out in 1721, that she had her daughter inoculated by this process of variolation, named after the smallpox virus itself. Again, Charles Maitland carried out the procedure—the first in Britain—which was much publicised.

Sadly, it was also greeted with much condemnation from the exclusively male scientific and medical communities. They were unimpressed by the fact that, in Turkey, variolation was usually carried out by elderly women with no education. Lady Mary was able to convince the Princess of Wales, Caroline of Ansbach, to take it seriously, however. In August of 1721, seven condemned prisoners awaiting execution at Newgate were offered variolation as an alternative. Not surprisingly, they accepted. All survived the experience, and were released.

In the East, inoculates knew that they must self-isolate after undergoing variolation, as live smallpox was used. In England this was not always understood or advised by medical practitioners. Nor was the dose of smallpox being administered always as tiny it was supposed to be, and some doctors bled and purged their patients unnecessarily. As a result, there were a number of deaths and complications. Politics and misinformation became involved, and Lady Mary’s reputation suffered as a result.

Nevertheless, having introduced smallpox inoculation to Western medicine, she continued to campaign for its widespread implementation. Edward Jenner built on the foundations of her work to come up with his vaccine. By doing so, on May 8th 1980, the World Health Assembly announced that the world was free of smallpox.

This year, it is 300 years since Lady Mary’s three-year-old daughter, also Mary, became the first person in the West to be protected against a deadly virus. To celebrate, award-winning TV drama and comedy producer, Jo Willett has penned a new biography of Lady Mary, celebrating the remarkable life of this early feminist among the greatest politicians, writers, artists, and thinkers of her day. Sounds like a brilliant story.

The Pioneering Life of Mary Wortley Montagu

–ooOoo–

This week’s Word of the Week is vaccination, created by Edward Jenner to describe his new treatment against smallpox. It comes from vacca, Latin for cow, from the cowpox virus Jenner used. (Although, Jenner experimented with horsepox virus as well, and when vials from 1902—which had contained the oldest known strains of smallpox vaccine—were subjected to DNA sequencing in 2017, scientists discovered it was more closely related to horsepox. So, perhaps that should be equusination?)